The Make-or-Break Moment: Why Manager Interview Questions Matter More Than You Think
Let's be honest - hiring the wrong manager can absolutely wreck your team's morale and productivity. When you're sitting across from a potential manager candidate, the questions you ask aren't just small talk. They're your crystal ball into how this person will lead, inspire, and guide your team through both smooth sailing and stormy weather. The right manager interview questions can reveal whether someone has the emotional intelligence to handle conflict, the strategic thinking to drive results, and the communication skills to keep everyone motivated and engaged.
The Shocking Reality of Management Hiring
Here's a stat that might make your jaw drop: companies get manager hiring wrong about 60% of the time, according to Gallup research. That's more than half of all management hires turning into expensive mistakes. Even more concerning? Only 48% of managers currently feel they have the know-how to excel in their positions. This isn't just about poor performance reviews - we're talking about real impact on people's lives and business outcomes.
The ripple effects are massive. A Gallup study found that a team's engagement is overwhelmingly determined by how they're managed. Think about that for a second. Managers have as much influence on their team's mental health as spouses do - a whopping 69% compared to doctors at 51%. When you consider that half the workforce is quietly checking out, which usually traces back to leadership issues, suddenly those manager interview questions become absolutely critical.
The Game-Changing Impact of Great Management
But here's the flip side that should get you excited: great managers are absolute game-changers. They can deliver 70% better employee wellbeing and 86% higher satisfaction with workplace relationships. Get this - 93% of employees with great managers feel energized and ready for anything. Those aren't just feel-good numbers; they translate directly into productivity, retention, and bottom-line results.
The challenge is that managing a team is by no means an easy position in which to survive and thrive. Burnout is common among managers, and their responsibilities are significantly different from individual contributor roles. All managers will have to deal with delegating workload and giving negative performance reviews from time to time. That's why your interview process needs to dig deep into their leadership philosophy, conflict resolution skills, and ability to maintain team stability.
Your Complete Guide to Manager Interview Success
Whether you're preparing 30 interview questions for managers, focusing on 20 common interview questions for a manager position, or diving into 10 essential questions for hiring managers, the key is understanding that management interviews focus on leadership abilities rather than just technical skills. You'll want to explore everything from decision-making and administration to writing skills, financial acumen, leadership style, performance evaluation, employee relations, planning, and organizational relationships.
Ready to transform your hiring process? We've compiled 234 best practice manager interview questions for 2025 that will help you identify those rare candidates who can truly lead, inspire, and deliver results for your organization.
Because you're reading this article, you might be interested in the following article as well: One Way Video Interview: Basics and Features.
🏆 The list of TOP 234 manager interview questions in 2025
How would you describe your management style?
This question helps uncover how a candidate leads others, makes decisions, and manages performance. You're looking for insight into how they communicate with their team, handle challenges, and foster growth.
A strong response should include:
- Clear communication and direction
- Empowering the team without micromanaging
- Being approachable for feedback and support
- Proven success with their style
In the response above, the candidate highlights several best practices:
- Trust in team members' judgment – shows confidence in delegating tasks
- Clear goals and direction – sets a focused tone for the team
- Openness to feedback and ideas – encourages collaboration
- Hands-off approach – suggests trust and reduces unnecessary oversight
- Proven track record – backs up their claims with real results like high productivity and retention
This is a solid answer. They're balancing structure with freedom, which is often the sweet spot for effective leadership. As a hiring manager, probe further by asking for examples of a time this approach worked well—or when it didn’t.
For more leadership interview questions, see this article.
Describe your work experience as a manager.
When screening candidates for managerial roles, this question helps you understand the depth and progression of their leadership journey. Look for clear growth over time, responsibilities they've owned, and how they’ve adapted to the demands of each stage.
In this case, the candidate has a solid timeline of six years in management, which is a strong indicator of stability and commitment. They began as a supervisor, which shows a natural progression into leadership. Moving from leading eight employees to managing five and now overseeing six reports as a strategic growth manager reveals steady advancement and broader responsibilities.
What to look for in an ideal answer:
- Progressive leadership roles
- Number of direct reports and team dynamics
- Contribution to broader business goals
- Clear examples of impact and results
Best practice tip: Encourage candidates to share outcomes tied to their leadership—metrics, team achievements, or cost savings. It shows they understand performance is about results, not just responsibility.
How do you motivate your team?
Motivation questions are key to understanding a candidate’s leadership style and emotional intelligence. When they talk about how they inspire their team, look for signs of empathy, adaptability, and people skills.
A strong response often includes a mix of:
- Knowing individual team members' preferences
- Using both positive reinforcement and constructive feedback
- Encouraging team collaboration
- Setting clear goals and celebrating wins
In the candidate's comment, they show a best practice approach by learning what drives each teammate through personal conversations. They understand that motivation isn't one-size-fits-all. Look for this kind of awareness during your candidate screening—someone who tailors their strategy based on the individual is likely to build a more engaged and productive team.
Listen for real examples, like helping their team exceed goals, which signals effective leadership that gets results.
How do you manage conflict between teammates?
This question helps evaluate a candidate's emotional intelligence, communication skills, and leadership potential. Conflict is bound to happen in any team, so you're looking for someone who can stay calm, fair, and constructive under pressure.
An ideal answer will show:
- Active listening
- Neutrality in conflict resolution
- A real example of a past situation
- A solution-focused mindset
Watch for: Candidates who take sides too quickly, avoid conflict entirely, or blame others without owning any part of the solution.
Best practice approach: Look for responses that show the candidate encouraged open dialogue and solved the problem in a way that helped the team grow. Those traits go a long way in building stronger team dynamics and improving results.
Tip: Ask follow-up questions to get more details on how their actions improved the outcome.
As a manager, how do you define success?
A great answer to this question shows whether the candidate's values align with the company's goals and if they have a team-first mindset. In management roles, success isn’t just about hitting metrics—it's about growing a team, leading effectively, and pushing the business forward.
Hiring managers should look for:
- Evidence of goal-setting and achievement
- Focus on both individual and team performance
- An understanding of how personal and team success ties into company objectives
A response like: “I define success as reaching both the company's and my personal goals, and assisting my team to do the same. I believe setting goals helps me put my best into each task and contribute to the company's objectives. As a manager, I prioritize helping my team meet milestones and motivating them to add value to the company.” is a strong one.
Why? Because it shows the candidate:
- Values goal-setting as a tool to stay focused
- Measures success not only personally but also through team outcomes
- Is committed to developing and inspiring others
Best practice: Look for candidates who understand that their success is tied to their team’s performance and the company’s mission. That’s a sign of a strong, supportive leader.
Give an example of a time you made a difficult decision in your management career
This question helps uncover a candidate’s decision-making ability, leadership style, and emotional intelligence. Difficult decisions are a regular part of any management role, so it’s important to hear how the candidate navigated this pressure.
A strong candidate will give a clear example from their past role where they had to balance objectivity, fairness, and business needs. Look for answers that show they took the time to evaluate all options and weighed the impact of their choice.
In this example:
> “In my last manager job, my company's CEO asked me to recommend a supervisor to promote to an assistant manager position. I had three excellent employees interested in the role, and they all had similar work experience. This meant I couldn't use their background or supervisory experience to inform my decision. Instead, I evaluated their performance and leadership skills. I also spoke to each candidate to understand their long-term goals. My decision proved vital because the candidate I recommended is now the head of their department.”
This is a great response because it shows:
- The candidate was in a real leadership situation with long-term team impact.
- They used a structured approach to evaluate based on merit and soft skills.
- They communicated well with the team by speaking individually to assess goals.
- Their judgment led to a successful outcome — a key sign of solid leadership.
Best practice tip: Ask probing follow-up questions like, “How did the other two team members respond to the decision?” or “What would you have done differently looking back?” This helps you assess how they manage team morale and feedback after tough calls.
How do you organize projects and delegate tasks to teammates?
This question helps evaluate a candidate's leadership style, organizational skills, and ability to work with others to complete a project efficiently. Look for signs of clear planning, communication, and a structured delegation approach. A strong answer should show strategic thinking, awareness of team dynamics, and use of tools or methods to manage workflows.
---
Ideal response indicators:
- Identifies team members’ strengths before assigning tasks
- Uses tools (like Trello, Asana, Microsoft Teams) to manage and track progress
- Practices open communication and regular updates with the team
- Monitors and adjusts workload when needed
- Encourages collaboration while maintaining accountability
---
What to listen for: In the sample comment, the candidate describes a democratic leadership style, considering teammates' competencies before assigning responsibilities. That’s a best practice — understanding what team members are good at leads to better results.
Using project management software is also a key advantage — it shows the candidate values efficiency and clarity. The mention of monthly progress reviews suggests they actively support and develop their team, rather than just delegate once and forget.
These are green flags. The candidate shows both a structured approach and a people-first mindset, which is essential for any leadership or coordination role.
How would you deal with an underperforming team member?
This question helps you understand how a candidate handles tough interpersonal situations and if they have the emotional intelligence and leadership skills needed for the role. Look for signs of empathy, accountability, and a clear process.
A strong answer will include these key elements:
- Recognizing the issue early
- Communicating with empathy
- Providing clear feedback
- Offering support or resources
- Following up consistently
Best practice: Top candidates won’t jump straight to discipline or blame. Instead, they'll aim to understand the root cause—like unclear expectations or personal challenges—before acting.
What to listen for: Did the candidate show patience and a plan? Did they collaborate with the team member? Was there follow-up?
For example, in this comment: > "In my four-year career, I've managed hardworking and dedicated teams and handled a few underperforming team members. If an employee were not meeting performance expectations, I'd politely reach out to them to discuss an improvement plan. We'd outline the required steps they need to take, and I'd follow up on them regularly."
This is a solid answer. It shows:
- Leadership experience
- A respectful approach to feedback
- Focus on improvement and accountability
Pro tip: Follow up with this: "Can you give an example of a time when you did this successfully?" This checks if they've done it in real life, not just in theory.
Have you ever promoted or terminated an employee? What was your reason?
This question digs into a candidate’s ability to handle leadership responsibilities — especially making tough calls. You're looking for real-life decision-making, not theory.
In the response below, the candidate explains promoting someone who consistently exceeded expectations. That’s a green flag — it shows they recognize and reward high performance based on measurable goals. Mentioning the use of forced-distribution review systems shows structure and a best-practice mindset when evaluating employees.
They also admit they haven’t terminated anyone yet but express readiness to do so if needed. That’s honest — and honesty matters. You want leaders who can face uncomfortable tasks head-on when necessary.
Best practice tip: Look for candidates who support promotions with clear outcomes and rationale. When it comes to terminations, even if they haven’t done it before, a thoughtful explanation of how they’d handle it tells you they’ve thought it through.
What is your greatest strength as a manager?
Comment: This is a strong, well-rounded answer. The candidate highlights motivating others as their top strength—a critical quality for any effective manager. It's even better that they back it up with a real example that involved improving employee retention, which is a pain point in many organizations.
This response shows the candidate can lead by understanding people and taking action to enhance team morale and productivity. It's also a sign of emotional intelligence and a proactive mindset.
Best practice: Look for candidates who don’t just list strengths but also explain how they’ve applied them to solve real problems. It shows that their strengths are not just theory—they drive real results.
How do you handle your mistakes at work?
This is a powerful question to assess a candidate’s level of accountability, honesty, and problem-solving skills.
A solid answer often includes these key elements:
- Admitting the mistake without blaming others
- Taking responsibility quickly
- Communicating openly with the team or supervisor
- Outlining how they fixed or learned from it
- Explaining what they’ll do to prevent future errors
What to look for: You want candidates who stay calm under pressure, act responsibly, and are willing to learn. Being able to say “I made a mistake and here’s how I handled it” can be more valuable than someone who never admits fault.
Red flags: If they blame others, avoid the question, or say they’ve never made a mistake—it may signal a lack of self-awareness or accountability.
Best practice approach: Encourage candidates to walk through a real example. This gives you insight into their thought process, communication style, and leadership potential, especially for higher-level or management roles.
Example of a strong response: "I believe accountability is an important trait to have as a manager because it sets the standard for my team. If I made a mistake at work, I'd apologize to the people involved and outline steps to prevent the error from recurring. I feel it's important to lead by example."
This kind of answer shows ownership, empathy, and a proactive mindset—all traits of a reliable and mature professional.
How have your previous roles shaped your managerial style?
Asking this question gives you valuable insight into a candidate’s management evolution over time. You're looking for more than just a summary of job titles—they should explain how those experiences influenced their leadership approach.
What to look for:
- Clear examples of growth or change in their style
- Specific roles that impacted their way of managing people
- A connection between past challenges and current leadership methods
Best practice:
Listen for self-awareness and reflection. Great managers learn from experience, so their story should include trial, feedback, and improvement. This helps you predict how they'll lead in your organization.
Candidates who can't clearly connect past roles to their management style may lack the depth or adaptability you're seeking in a leader.
Have you always identified as a leader?
This question explores your leadership identity and self-perception throughout your career. It helps hiring managers understand if the candidate naturally gravitates toward leadership roles or if leadership is something they’ve developed over time.
What to look for:
- A clear yes often shows confidence and a natural inclination toward leading.
- A thoughtful no can show personal growth and intentional development.
- Listen for examples of how leadership showed up early in their career or even outside of work.
- Pay attention to how they describe their leadership style — is it collaborative, directive, supportive?
Best practice approach: Follow up with questions like:
- “Can you share a moment when you first took initiative in a group setting?”
- “How has your view on leadership changed over time?”
This keeps the conversation focused and helps you see how self-awareness and leadership mindset have shaped their journey.
What are your career goals for the next five years?
This question assesses your long-term vision and career planning abilities.
It’s important to understand where a candidate sees themselves professionally in the future. Their answer can reveal motivation, ambition, and whether they align with your company’s direction. Look for responses that show clear goals, realistic timelines, and a growth mindset.
What to look for:
- A balance between ambition and realism
- Alignment with the role or company vision
- A desire to grow within the company or industry
Red flags:
- Vague or unclear objectives
- Goals not related to the job or your industry
- Plans that indicate short-term engagement
Best practice: Ask follow-up questions to clarify how their five-year plan fits with the role you're hiring for. This helps ensure mutual long-term value.
What excites you the most about working in a management role? What excites you the least?
This question digs into the candidate’s motivation, self-awareness, and understanding of what it really means to be in a leadership position. It helps you understand not just if they can manage, but if they’re emotionally and mentally aligned with what the role requires.
Best practice: Look for answers that reflect leadership values like mentoring, decision-making, and strategic thinking. Watch out for red flags where candidates focus only on authority or control.
What to look for in a strong response:
- Excitement about leadership responsibilities: Delegating, coaching, or developing team members.
- Awareness of challenges: Maybe they mention handling conflict or balancing workloads — but more importantly, they explain how they manage or overcome those challenges.
- Alignment with company culture: Responses should match the way your company views leadership.
Example of a thoughtful answer:
"What excites me the most about working in a management role is the opportunity to help team members grow and succeed. I love building a positive environment where people feel supported and able to do their best work. What excites me the least about management is handling performance issues. While it's never easy, I've learned to approach these situations with empathy and clear communication to ensure fairness and improvement."
Tip: Avoid candidates who struggle to mention any downside — it may suggest a lack of practical experience. Balanced self-reflection shows maturity and readiness for leadership.
Why do you want to take on a leadership role for our company?
This question helps you understand a candidate’s true motivation for taking on a leadership position—and why your company, in particular, stands out to them.
You're looking for more than a generic answer. A strong response will show:
- Alignment with your company’s mission or values
- Real interest in leading your team, not just any team
- Awareness of your company culture and leadership needs
Best practice: Look for candidates who mention something unique about your organization—your growth, your challenges, or your industry position. That shows they’ve done their research and are not just looking for any leadership title.
A red flag is a vague answer like “I’m ready to be a leader” without mentioning your company specifically. You want candidates who want to grow with you, not just somewhere else.
Ask follow-ups like:
- “What about our current team or goals inspires you to lead here?”
- “How do you see your leadership making an impact at our company?”
Use this question to separate candidates who are just chasing a title from those who want to build something with you.
Have you ever had to make a decision without all the necessary information? How did you handle the situation?
This is a great question to assess problem-solving, critical thinking, and risk management skills. In many roles, especially in fast-paced environments, employees won’t always have complete information. The way a candidate navigates that uncertainty can reveal a lot.
Look for responses that highlight:
- Confidence and composure under pressure
- A logical and structured approach to decision-making
- Effective use of available data and resources
- Collaboration — did they ask for help or input from others?
- Evaluation of potential risks
Best practice: A strong candidate will show that they can make smart decisions without getting paralyzed by missing information. They should demonstrate that they weighed the pros and cons, considered alternatives, and took ownership of the outcome.
Watch out for answers that suggest impulsive choices or a complete reliance on others to make decisions for them. You want someone who takes initiative but knows how to manage uncertainty responsibly.
How do you involve your team members in the decision-making process?
This question evaluates your collaborative leadership style and team engagement approach. It helps employers understand if you foster teamwork and value diverse input. The best candidates will share how they:
- Seek feedback from team members regularly
- Create open forums or meetings to encourage diverse perspectives
- Transparently share information so decisions are made with context
- Give credit and ownership to team members for their contributions
Best practice tip: Look for candidates who can give real examples of collaboration—not just generic answers. Strong responses often include how involving the team led to better results, improved morale, or enhanced innovation.
This is especially important for managerial or leadership roles, where collaboration drives long-term success.
Tell me about a time you made a decision that wasn't popular with the majority of the team. How did you handle it?
This question helps you understand how a candidate deals with conflict, makes independent decisions, and manages team dynamics under pressure.
What to look for in a strong response:
- A clear description of the decision and the context around it
- The reasoning behind the decision
- How the candidate communicated the choice
- The steps taken to manage disagreement or resistance
- Whether the decision led to a positive outcome later on
You want to see that the candidate can stand by their principles while also being empathetic and communicative. Best practice here is to value candidates who don’t just go with the crowd, but also know how to keep the team aligned.
Red flags to watch out for:
- They blame the team or avoid responsibility
- They don’t explain their reasoning or show weak communication skills
- There’s no resolution or learning in the end
This question reveals a lot about their leadership capabilities, accountability, and team collaboration skills—even if the role isn't managerial.
Do you welcome your direct reports to challenge your decisions or ask questions about how you reach conclusions?
This question sheds light on a candidate’s leadership style—especially how open and collaborative they are with their team. The best leaders create an environment where team members feel safe and respected when sharing different opinions.
What to look for:
- A clear “yes” to encouraging open dialogue
- Real examples of when a team member challenged them and how they handled it
- Signs they value feedback, no matter where it comes from
Best practice: Look for candidates who see questions and pushback as opportunities to improve—not as threats. Leaders who truly believe in transparency and collaboration are more likely to build trust and motivate their teams. Avoid candidates who seem defensive or dismissive when others challenge their views.
How would you describe your communication style?
This question helps uncover how a candidate interacts with others at work, both verbally and in writing. Look for answers that reflect self-awareness and an ability to adjust their communication based on the audience or situation.
What to listen for:
- Clear understanding of their own communication habits.
- Examples of adapting style to different colleagues or teams.
- Mention of key traits like clarity, active listening, openness, or directness.
Best practice approach: A strong candidate will give a brief description followed by real-life examples—this shows they not only know their style but have practiced it successfully in the workplace.
You might also hear red flags like extremely passive or aggressive styles, lack of adaptability, or overly vague answers. Inconsistent communication can hurt collaboration, so stay alert to how well they're able to articulate their approach.
How do you approach giving constructive feedback to team members, both positive and negative?
Giving feedback is a key part of being a strong team player or a leader. The goal is to understand how the candidate communicates—especially when it’s not all good news. Look for answers that show empathy, clarity, and a commitment to helping others grow.
What strong answers include:
- A structured approach to feedback (e.g. “situation-behavior-impact” model)
- Balancing both positive and corrective feedback
- Timing and tone—giving feedback in private when needed
- Encouraging two-way communication
- Real examples of when feedback led to improvement
Best practice tip: A great candidate won’t just talk about giving negative feedback. They’ll also highlight the importance of celebrating wins and reinforcing what’s going well.
Red flags to watch for:
- Avoiding tough conversations
- Being overly critical or vague
- Lack of real-life examples
Why it matters: This question evaluates performance management, emotional intelligence, and team leadership. Candidates who handle feedback well help build a high-trust, high-performing team.
How do you deal with performance issues?
This question assesses your ability to address and resolve team performance challenges.
A strong candidate will show a mix of communication skills, objectivity, and a proactive mindset. Look for answers that include:
- Clear identification of the performance issue
- Direct and respectful conversations with the employee
- Use of data or examples to explain the performance gap
- Steps taken to support improvement (like training, resources, or new goals)
- Willingness to follow up and evaluate progress
Red flags: Avoiding confrontation, blaming others, or showing no clear process.
Best practice approach: Top candidates typically handle performance issues by first understanding the root cause before jumping to conclusions. They focus on coaching and improvement rather than punishment.
What's your balance between being a leader and a team player?
This is a great question to evaluate if a candidate understands how to lead while still collaborating smoothly with others. You're looking for someone who can switch hats depending on the situation — someone who can guide a team when needed but also step back and contribute when others are leading.
What to look for in a strong answer:
- Clear understanding of when to lead and when to support
- Examples of past experiences where they demonstrated both roles
- Willingness to adapt based on team needs or project goals
- Emphasis on communication, listening, and collaboration
Best practice approach: Look for candidates who show self-awareness and flexibility. A balanced answer often means they know their strengths but also recognize value in shared success.
Avoid rigid responses like “I only like to lead” or “I prefer to follow.” Great team members can shift roles naturally.
Can you describe a specific example of making a decision that put the team's needs before your own?
This question helps reveal if a candidate has a team-first mindset—something crucial for collaborative, high-performing work environments. You're looking for answers that show maturity, emotional intelligence, and leadership, even if the candidate isn't applying for a formal leadership role.
What to listen for:
- A clear situation where the candidate had to make a tough choice.
- How they identified that the team’s needs came first.
- The action they took and the positive outcome that followed.
- Reflection on what they learned and why they made that decision.
Red flags:
- Vague or self-centered answers.
- Stories where they present themselves as the hero without real sacrifice.
- No clear impact on the team.
Best practice: Probe deeper if the response is too general. This question works best as part of a behavioral interview—use follow-up questions like "What was the result?" or "Would you do anything differently now?" to get the full picture.
How do you prioritize tasks for effective project management? What strategies do you use to ensure team members are clear on responsibilities?
This question helps you understand the candidate’s approach to managing work efficiently and leading a team. You're not just looking for buzzwords—you want a clear, practical explanation of how they organize tasks, make decisions under pressure, and communicate responsibilities to others.
What to look for in strong answers:
- Clear use of project management tools (like Trello, Asana, or Jira).
- Mention of prioritization techniques like Eisenhower Matrix, MoSCoW method, or time-blocking.
- A methodical approach to delegating tasks and setting clear expectations.
- Strategies for team alignment, such as regular stand-up meetings, shared dashboards, or written documentation.
Best practice: Strong candidates will explain how they balance deadlines with task importance and how they follow up to ensure accountability. You want someone who provides structure and clarity—especially under pressure.
Red flags to watch:
- Vague answers like “I just make a list” or “I try my best.”
- Not mentioning specific tools or examples of collaboration.
- No process in place to follow up or confirm task completion.
Can you tell me about a time when a project didn't go to plan? How did you get back on course?
This question is key to understanding how a candidate handles setbacks, pressure, and unexpected changes. Every job comes with challenges—what matters is how someone responds to them.
What to look for in a strong answer:
- A clear example with context: What went wrong and why?
- Evidence of ownership and not just blaming others
- Problem-solving skills and quick thinking
- Flexibility and ability to adapt
- Communication and teamwork during the crisis
- A focus on outcomes—what changed, and what was learned?
Best practice is to look for the STAR method in responses:
- Situation: What was the project?
- Task: What was their responsibility?
- Action: What steps did they take to fix the issue?
- Result: Did they succeed? What did they learn?
A red flag is someone who avoids responsibility or gives vague examples. You're looking for resourcefulness, resilience, and a positive mindset when things go off-track.
How do you measure the success of a project beyond completing it on time?
This question evaluates your understanding of comprehensive success metrics and strategic thinking.
Many projects finish on schedule, but that doesn't always mean they were truly successful. A great candidate goes beyond timeframes and talks about things like:
- Staying within budget
- Meeting key objectives and KPIs
- Client or stakeholder satisfaction
- Quality of the final deliverable
- Team performance and collaboration
- Lessons learned and process improvements
Best practice is to listen for candidates who reflect on results, not just timelines. Strong responses might include data points, feedback received, or examples of how their project impacted larger business goals. These types of answers show a big-picture thinker with a strategic mindset.
Look for candidates who don’t just do the task, but also understand the why behind it.
How do you align short-term project goals with a company's long-term strategic objectives?
This question helps uncover how candidates think beyond immediate tasks and connect their work to the bigger picture. You're looking for someone who doesn't just complete projects but ensures their work supports the company's mission and future goals.
What to look for in a good answer:
- A clear understanding of the company’s long-term vision.
- Ability to break down strategic goals into actionable short-term steps.
- Focus on communication, collaboration, and regular check-ins to stay aligned.
- Examples of past projects where they successfully did this.
Best practice tip: A strong candidate will show they actively seek understanding of business direction and adjust their project planning to serve that.
Red flags to watch for:
- Vague or overly generic responses.
- Lack of connection between task execution and company objectives.
- No past examples or insight into their approach.
Use this question early in project management, leadership, or strategic roles to gauge big-picture thinking.
How do you decide what tasks to delegate and which to handle yourself?
This question helps gauge a candidate's prioritization, leadership style, and self-awareness. You're looking for someone who knows how to balance their workload and trust others when appropriate.
A strong answer should reflect:
- An organized decision-making process
- Awareness of team strengths and personal limitations
- The ability to think strategically about resources and outcomes
What to listen for:
- Do they assess task urgency, complexity, and priority?
- Do they understand their own strengths vs. the team's?
- Can they give examples of when delegation worked well?
Best practice: Look for answers with a clear framework or logic. The candidate should not be holding on to tasks out of control issues or fear of accountability.
Sample insight: > "Every project or task is different, and my approach is always to examine the scope of each project first. I start by weighing out urgency, complexity, and what skills are required. I prefer different approaches for urgent vs. less timely tasks to ensure optimal results."
This is a strong response—it shows forethought, an adaptable approach, and careful evaluation of both the work and the people available.
💡 Remaining 204 questions...
The online article only includes the first 30 questions to keep it digestible, but we’ve put together an ebook for you with all the questions we gathered through our extensive research.
Download E-Book here 👉
Real-World Success Stories: How Companies Master Manager Interview Questions
Leading organizations and career experts have developed proven strategies for evaluating management candidates. Sling's recruitment team has created comprehensive lists of top manager interview questions that keep their hiring process both thorough and candidate-friendly. Their approach focuses on real-world scenarios rather than theoretical questions, helping them identify managers who can actually lead teams effectively.
Alli Polin, leadership expert and Founder of Break the Frame Consulting, emphasizes that companies need to dig deeper than surface-level answers. "The company wants to understand your philosophy and leadership style—not answers learned by rote," Polin explains. She notes that organizations are particularly interested in candidates' views on company culture to ensure they align with future direction.
Tameka Nikki Andrews, founder of creative consulting agency Flannel and Blade, brings valuable perspective from managing teams across multiple industries. Andrews stresses the importance of incorporating diversity, equity, and inclusion into manager interview questions. Her approach helps companies identify leaders who can build inclusive teams and foster belonging in the workplace.
CareerVidz, with over 5 million subscribers, has seen significant success with their management interview preparation content. Richard McMunn, their management skills coach, provides practical guidance for first-time managers facing interviews. The channel's popularity demonstrates the high demand for quality manager interview preparation resources.
Career counseling experts at The Muse have developed structured approaches to manager interviews. MIT career counselor Lily Zhang recommends using a present-past-future formula when answering leadership questions, while former recruiter Richard Moy focuses on candidates' willingness to face challenges head-on. These proven frameworks help both candidates and hiring managers navigate complex leadership discussions more effectively.
Donovan Training has built their reputation on preparing first-time managers for success. Their dedicated training programs focus on practical skills development, with online leadership courses that complement traditional interview preparation. This comprehensive approach has helped countless professionals transition into management roles.
Why Video Screening Software is Revolutionizing Manager Recruitment
The recruitment landscape is rapidly evolving, and video screening software is becoming an essential tool for hiring managers effectively. Traditional phone screenings often miss crucial non-verbal cues that are vital when evaluating leadership potential. Video interviews allow recruiters to assess communication skills, confidence levels, and cultural fit much more accurately.
Time efficiency is another major driver of adoption. Instead of scheduling multiple in-person interviews for manager interview questions, recruiters can review recorded video responses at their convenience. This flexibility speeds up the entire hiring process while maintaining quality standards.
The technology also enables standardized evaluation processes. Every candidate answers the same set of manager interview questions in the same format, reducing bias and ensuring fair comparison. This consistency is particularly valuable when hiring for management positions where leadership qualities need careful assessment.
Remote work trends have accelerated video screening adoption even further. Companies can now evaluate management candidates from anywhere in the world, expanding their talent pool significantly. The ability to record and review interviews multiple times also helps hiring teams make more informed decisions about leadership hires.
Ready to streamline your manager recruitment process? Discover how CandidateScreenings.com can transform your hiring workflow and help you identify the best management talent efficiently.